Will Spencer

Will Spencer

The One Answer the Far Right Can't Allow

Why white grievance always ends up at war with Christ

Will Spencer's avatar
Will Spencer
Nov 17, 2026
The One Answer the Far Right Can't Allow

This past week my friend Ethan (@not_our_guy on X, NOT_OUR_GUY on Substack) was digging into the old white nationalist & white supremacist writers, and he made an important observation: trace any of them back far enough and they end up hating Christianity, every single time.

There’s a reason for that. And believe it or not, the logic runs in a straight line.

X avatar for @not_our_guy
Hitler Hated Christ@not_our_guy
There's a particularly silly idea that has become popular among certain christian Nationalists and traditionalist Catholics that belief in the Holocaust constitutes adherence to some sort of counterfeit religion called "Holocaustianity". It's also tied up with the catchall …
10:27 PM · Nov 12, 2026 · 19.4K Views

27 Replies · 38 Reposts · 165 Likes

The problem they couldn’t solve

The old white power writers had a big problem, and for decades they couldn’t crack it. It’s this:

Before you can run grievance politics on behalf of a race, you have to convince people the race exists as an identity.

Oldschool white power leaders like Wilmot Robertson (from Ethan’s tweet), George Lincoln Rockwell and William Pierce kept running into this problem from the 1950’s onward. Robertson wrote in his white power classic The Dispossessed Majority (1972) that “an unmistakable sign of racelessness, a synonym for powerlessness in a multiracial state, is a generalized apathy towards the subject of racial origins.” He’s arguing that white people—the dispossessed majority from his book title—were rendered powerless in America due to their apathy towards matters of their own race.

Robertson wasn’t the first to make this observation, though. George Lincoln Rockwell, founder of the American Nazi Party in 1959, wrote that the first task of anyone who would save civilization is “to make White men supremely and totally conscious of RACE above all other allegiances.”

In the simplest terms, for the early white power guys there was no white identity to appeal to. As a result, there was no one to sell white grievance to. They had supply, but no demand. Because white men in America didn’t wake up every day thinking of themselves as white, and they certainly didn’t wake up feeling oppressed for it, like the white power leaders wanted them to.

So those leaders recognized they had to create the identity before they could sell the grievance. They never managed to do either.

Then wokeness solved it for them

And then? Miracle of miracles, “critical race theory” (CRT) and “diversity, equity, and inclusion” (DEI) did all the heavy lifting for them! And that solved both problems at once.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Will Spencer.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Will Spencer · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.